The Legal Examiner Affiliate Network The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner search feed instagram google-plus avvo phone envelope checkmark mail-reply spinner error close
Skip to main content
Raymond Allard, D.O., Engages in “Bizarre” Behavior at Sparrow Hospital, Causing Infections in Patients; Sparrow Covers it Up
Grewal Law, PLLC
(888) 211-5798

Raymond Phillip Allard, D.O., who was an orthopedic surgeon at Sparrow Health System and Sparrow Carson Hospital until recently, is currently under investigation by Michigan’s Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs (LARA) and the Healthcare Facilities Accreditation Program (HFAP) due to complaints made by a nurse anesthetist.  Sparrow Carson Hospital is also under investigation by LARA and the HFAP.

Officials at Sparrow were aware that Dr. Allard was engaging in very unsafe surgical practices, such as intentionally leaving surgical sponges in a patient’s infected surgical wound and closing the wound with the sponges inside.  Nurse Anesthetist Jonnie Vanderhoef informed senior officials at Sparrow Carson Hospital numerous times about Dr. Allard’s unsafe medical practices and total disregard for patient safety.  In fact, Vanderhoef even met with the hospital’s CEO, Matthew Thompson, to discuss Dr. Allard’s dangerous surgical practices, but Sparrow officials did not stop Dr. Allard from performing surgery on patients.

Vanderhoef informed LARA officials in November, 2017, that Sparrow “knowingly and willfully” concealed Allard’s “dangerous surgical activity.”

“Dr. Allard continues a history of excessively high surgical complications, including severe infections,” Vanderhoef wrote in his complaint. “His behavior and deviation from accepted medical practice has become more bizarre in recent weeks.”

Indeed, Sparrow Carson Hospital officials knew of Dr. Allard’s bizarre behavior and disregard for patient safety for at least 9 months before any action was taken.  This means that Dr. Allard continued to perform surgery on numerous patients during those months.  Sadly, no less than 18 infections related to Dr. Allard’s surgeries and procedures were reported during this time period.

Dr. Allard did not stop working at Sparrow Health System and Sparrow Carson Hospital until his dangerous practices were reported to LARA.  And it is not even clear that Sparrow took action at this time.  According to Sparrow officials, Dr. Allard “voluntarily suspended his medical privileges at Sparrow Carson Hospital.”

Dr. Allard has been an orthopedic surgeon for almost thirty years, performing procedures such as total knee arthroplasty (TKA).  He has been employed by Sparrow Health System and Sparrow Carson Hospital for 9 years.  Dr. Allard has also practiced at Sheridan Community Hospital, Spectrum Health Kelsey Hospital, Spectrum Health United Memorial – United Campus, Carson Hospital, and Montcalm Center for Orthopedic Excellence, P.C.

Dr. Allard had been investigated numerous times by LARA.  In his complaints, Vanderhoef wrote that other staff members had expressed concerns about Dr. Allard, but they failed to take action due to fear.  LARA began investigating Sparrow Carson Hospital and Dr. Allard on November 2, 2017.  On November 3, 2017, Vanderhoef was fired.

Preventable medical mistakes are the third leading cause of death in the U.S., and many hospitals and medical facilities appear to be doing the opposite of what they should be doing to halt this medical error epidemic.  Sparrow terminated Vanderhoef for simply trying to make the hospital safer for patients.

The medical malpractice attorneys at Church Wyble, P.C. have spent decades uncovering medical mistakes and fighting for justice for victims of medical mistakes.  The attorneys have made it their mission to stop hospital cover ups.  If you have suffered an injury due to medical malpractice, please contact the medical malpractice attorneys at Church Wyble, P.C. for a free consultation.


  1. Gravatar for Jonnie Vanderhoef
    Jonnie Vanderhoef

    Thanks for printing this!

    Raymond Allard is Sparrow's "Larry Nassar!"

  2. Gravatar for Ellen

    He is not the only one Sparrow has pvered up for.

  3. Gravatar for Ellen

    He is not the only one Sparrow has covered up for.

  4. Gravatar for Kelly Reed
    Kelly Reed

    Dr. Allards behavior is nothing new. I worked with him when he started at Carson City Hospital until 2008. His commented about patients bodies, attempted to pick up women both staff and patient, his general lack of knowledge for certain medical problems and medications, and his playboy attitude was just a joke to management. Nothing was done about complaints against him. No records of his behavior apparently they knew nothing about it. He was seen on a regular basis drinking at the bar until late into the evening and just a few hours before surgery. He often smelled like the previous nights beer. I really don't think Sparrow Hospital knew of his behavior when they took the Carson City Hospital over. In fact, I don't believe they know half of whats going because Carson City still has the good old boy practice. This problem and others has gone on for years so we are glad Jon Vanderhoef finally was able to get someones attention. He is our hero and we will stand behind him. He finally did what many of us have lost our jobs trying to do. He should share a cell with Nasser.

  5. Gravatar for Kelly Reed
    Kelly Reed

    Dr. Allard should share the cell with Nassar. Not mr. Vanderhoef!

  6. Gravatar for Linda Kelly
    Linda Kelly

    Dr All are botched up my ankle, had to have a second surgery to try to repair his mistakes. Swelling and infection from the staples. Spent 6 months in a wheel chair. Arthritis will set in and will eventually have to have another surgery to place artificial ankle in. Never showed any trays in his office. Seeked 2 different attorneys. Checked out his background but things were covered up. Sexual harassment and medical malpractice. I am one of his victims.

  7. Gravatar for Kathleen Maynard
    Kathleen Maynard

    I read about this physician on Becker's, and Googled him (Dr. Allard). He was convicted of mail fraud (copped a plea) for trying to PURCHASE a med school diploma. What kind of hospital would give practice privileges to a physician with that on his record?? Kudos to Jonnie Vanderhoef for having the guts to follow through with this. Please see my whistle-blowing Facebook page, "UF Health Shands Hospital Gainesville Florida-Unofficial".

Comments for this article are closed, but you may still contact the author privately.